Credit Reporting Agencies Responsible for Watch List Errors

By Teresa Anderson


TransUnion again appealed. The credit reporting agency argued that it only reported the OFAC information and should not be held responsible for its accuracy. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit disagreed, upholding the lower court’s verdict. The appellate court ruled that TransUnion was responsible for the accuracy of the OFAC information if the agency chose to list it on credit reports.

The court noted that the credit report did not say that Cortez was a “possible” match or had a name “similar” to someone on the OFAC list. Instead it reported a “match” with someone on the list. However, TransUnion’s records showed that Cortez was born in 1944 and her middle name was Jean. The person on the OFAC list was named Sandra Quintero Cortes and was born in 1971. Despite this information, TransUnion placed a notice on Cortez’s credit report stating “input name matches name on the OFAC database.”

The court was clear about TransUnion’s responsibility in the matter and noted that the OFAC information is no different from that received from creditors or public record and credit agencies. The court also said credit reporting agencies are responsible for ensuring that the information is correct.

In the written opinion of the case, the court noted that “Congress clearly intended to ensure that credit reporting agencies exercise care when deciding to associate information with a given consumer, and the record clearly supports the jury’s determination that TransUnion did not exercise sufficient care here.”

♦ Snapshot of TransUnion Web site


Credit reports are

Credit reports are constantly updated with new information; most banks report new customer data every 30 days. It is voluntary for banks and creditors report to the credit bureaus. They are utilized to authenticate all information given during the application, most importantly, the amount of unsettled debt and specific number of creditors. Because majority of the applicants usually forget and overlook all exact details, discrepancies in storing information may occur.
Credit reporting agencies

View Recent News (by day)


Beyond Print

SM Online

See all the latest links and resources that supplement the current issue of Security Management magazine.