Teacher Can Sue For Being Spied On While Getting Naked On Stolen Laptop

By Carlton Purvis

Did a laptop recovery company cross the line when it took screen captures of a woman using a stolen laptop to have sexually explicit chats over webcam with her boyfriend? Would it make a difference if they did it to provide the pictures to law enforcement? Those questions will be in the hands of a jury after a judge ruled that the woman and her boyfriend can sue the company for invasion of privacy.

Clark County School District in Ohio often checks out laptops to its students to use at school and at home. After a trip to the local library, one student had a school-issued laptop stolen. The laptop ended up being sold a couple times between students and as it passed hands, somewhere along the line, the serial number was removed from the computer.

Fortunately for Clark County School District, they’d enrolled in a program with Absolute Software that could recover stolen laptops--no serial number needed. Using just the computer’s IP address, the company can gain complete access to a computer and all of its files the next time it connects to the Internet. It can also watch a person’s activities in real time and record their keystrokes.

Unfortunately for 52-year-old substitute teacher Susan Clements-Jeffrey, she was in possession of the computer when Absolute activated its services and began tracking the laptop. As part of its investigation, Kyle Magnus, a theft recovery officer at Absolute recorded her keystrokes, IP address, and monitored her visits to Web sites. A few days later, he also captured screen shots of a webcam chat between Clements-Jeffrey and her boyfriend where she “is not wearing any clothes” and “has her legs spread apart.”

That same day, Magnus then turned the information he collected in to the Springfield Police--including the explicit pictures. The next day the police showed up at her house (without a warrant) with the pictures and she was arrested for receiving stolen property. The charges were later dropped and now Clements-Jeffrey has been cleared to sue the plaintiffs, Absolute Software (for invasion of privacy) and the Springfield Police (for searching her apartment without a warrant).


crossing the line

 That's really crossing the line, in my opinion. However, I always advise my clients to be judicious about what they do over webcam. Less tech-savvy clients don't know how to detect that things are being monitored. Furthermore, there are some video chat programs that have built-in recorders Video Chat Rounds on Facebook is just the latest example - ). You can never be too careful over webcam, especially if you might be involved in divorce proceedings. ;)

View Recent News (by day)


Beyond Print

SM Online

See all the latest links and resources that supplement the current issue of Security Management magazine.