Two Months Later, Post Columnist Sticking to His Account of 'TSA Scam'

By Carlton Purvis

After a New York Post columnist reported an alleged scam by TSA agents on Sept. 11, TSA fired back through its blog. Sports columnist Phil Mushnick said that not only did he witness a TSA agent taking money to move passengers to the front of the line, he participated in the scam to see if it would actually work. After his party was ushered to the front of the line by who he said was a TSA agent, who then asked him to pay cash for the service, he wrote about it for his Sept. 11 column.

“This uniformed airport security officer wasn't on the lookout for suspicious characters or even infirm passengers, she was on the lookout for extra cash,” he wrote. “Nine years and 11 months after 9/11, it was all so easy. And it was appalling.”

What Mushnick didn’t realize, says TSA, was that the person who whisked his friend to the front of the line in a wheel chair, Mushnick and his wife in tow, was a skycap not a TSA agent. And skycaps work for tips, which is why the woman asked for cash. After taking them to the front of the line, she patiently waited on the other side of the security checkpoint for them.

TSA says not only was Mushnick mistaken in thinking she was a TSA agent, but he also timed the release of his column to coincide with Sept. 11. The incident happened on August 12. His column wasn’t published until a month later.

In a letter to New York Post editors, TSA says video of the incident clearly shows a skycap taking Mushnick and his party to the front of the line. “…in pulling off his caper, he falsely accused a blue-uniformed TSA officer of being the one who solicited the service, pushed the wheelchair and accepted the cash tip. There is absolutely no comparison between a white skycap outfit and a blue TSA uniform!"

“Mushnick himself was guilty of a hustle by paying off a skycap and having a travel companion pretend to be disabled to circumvent a line. His actions and falsely accusing TSA are unacceptable,” TSA spokesperson Lisa Farbstein said.
“We requested that he run a clarification, and he did not. We wrote a letter to the editor and they declined to run it,” Farbstein told Security Management.

The Post is the eighth largest newspaper in the United States based on circulation, according to, so TSA’s concerns came from such wide dissemination of inaccurate information.

Security Management caught up with Mushnick a couple weeks ago as he headed home from a round of golf--and he’s sticking to his story.


This guy's so full of it...

So, a TSA agent is hustling passengers for tips for head of line service, in plain view - in front of several other TSA agents?  Really??  And even after TSA explains what I see on a daily basis - a skycap helps a disabled passenger through the checkpoint - skycaps at ALL airports wheel their customers to the front of the line, go through screening themselves, and await their customer on the "clean" side.  And have you BEEN to New York lately?  Ride the NYC Airporter from Laguardia into Manhattan sometime, and you'll see the exact same behavior - the drivers do not wait for a passenger to hand them a tip, the driver digs into the passenger, "Don't forget the tip, don't forget the tip, don't forget the tip" OVER AND OVER.  Only in New York.  I seriously doubt these bus drivers work for less than minimum wage, and when I get hassled for tips, I usually give WAY less than I would have otherwise.  At any rate, if Mr. Mushnik was any kind of serious journalist, he'd have gotten a few cell phone pics or video of his or someone else's experience as evidence.  This appears to be a clear case of a drama queen not understanding the environment.

View Recent News (by day)


Beyond Print

SM Online

See all the latest links and resources that supplement the current issue of Security Management magazine.